We're Always Open Call Us Today!

Can a Broken Water Heater Cause Carbon Monoxide? Unveiling the Truth

Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas that is highly toxic, making it a significant safety concern in homes. One common cause of carbon monoxide leaks in residential spaces comes from faulty or improperly maintained combustion appliances, such as water heaters.

Water heaters are typically powered by natural gas, propane, or electricity, producing combustion gases as a byproduct. When a water heater is functioning correctly, these gases are safely vented to the outdoors, preventing buildup or exposure inside homes. However, if a water heater malfunctions or becomes damaged, there is a potential risk of carbon monoxide leaking into living spaces.

In the case of a broken or damaged water heater, several factors can contribute to the release of carbon monoxide. Some of the most common causes include a disconnected or corroded vent pipe, insufficient combustion air, or a damaged heat exchanger. It is crucial to maintain and inspect water heaters regularly to identify and address any potential issues before they become hazardous.

Can a Broken Water Heater Cause Carbon Monoxide?

A broken water heater can potentially cause carbon monoxide (CO) build-up, which poses a serious health risk. Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas that is produced when fuels, such as natural gas or propane, are burned incompletely. In well-maintained water heaters, the combustion process is efficient, and CO is safely vented outside. However, certain issues can lead to incomplete combustion and the release of CO into the living spaces.

There are several reasons a water heater might malfunction and lead to carbon monoxide production:

  • Blocked or leaking vent: The venting system is responsible for removing CO from the water heater and directing it outside. Obstructions, such as debris or nests, can reduce air circulation, resulting in an increase in CO levels. A leaking vent can also release CO back into the living spaces.
  • Insufficient airflow: Good airflow around the water heater is essential for proper combustion of the fuel. If the area does not have enough ventilation or the water heater is located in a cramped space, insufficient oxygen may be available for complete combustion.
  • Wrong fuel-to-air ratio: A balanced fuel-to-air ratio is necessary for the proper combustion of fuel. If the ratio is not correct, it may result in incomplete combustion and higher CO emissions.
  • Dirty components: Over time, dirt and grime can accumulate on components like burners and heat exchangers, resulting in a decrease in combustion efficiency. As a result, the water heater may produce more CO than it should.

To prevent carbon monoxide poisoning and ensure the safe operation of your water heater, periodic maintenance is crucial. Regular inspections, cleaning, and timely repairs can help avoid the risks associated with a broken water heater. Additionally, installing CO detectors in your home is a critical safety measure that can alert you to elevated levels of this dangerous gas.

Sources of Carbon Monoxide in Homes

Understanding the common sources of carbon monoxide in residential settings is essential in order to prevent poisoning and maintain a safe living environment. This section will discuss gas water heaters, furnaces, fireplaces, and kitchen appliances as potential sources of carbon monoxide.

Gas Water Heaters

Gas water heaters can be a source of carbon monoxide if they are not properly vented or maintained. A blocked or damaged vent can cause carbon monoxide to build up inside the home. It is important to have gas water heaters inspected and serviced regularly by a qualified professional to ensure safe operation.


Furnaces, particularly those powered by natural gas or other fossil fuels, can release carbon monoxide as a byproduct of combustion. To minimize the risk, homeowners should:

  • Install carbon monoxide detectors near furnaces to monitor levels
  • Ensure proper ventilation and adherence to manufacturer guidelines
  • Schedule annual maintenance with a licensed technician


Both wood-burning and gas fireplaces can be sources of carbon monoxide. For wood-burning fireplaces:

  • Keep the chimney clean and free of obstructions
  • Use seasoned wood to reduce harmful emissions

For gas fireplaces:

  • Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for use and maintenance
  • Keep vents clear to allow proper ventilation
  • Install a carbon monoxide detector nearby

Kitchen Appliances

Gas stoves, ovens, and other kitchen appliances can emit carbon monoxide if not properly maintained and vented. To reduce the risk of carbon monoxide exposure:

  • Use range hoods or exhaust fans when cooking
  • Check for proper venting and appliance installation
  • Regularly clean and maintain appliances

Signs of a Broken Water Heater

Recognizing the signs of a broken water heater can help prevent carbon monoxide exposure and other risks associated with malfunctioning appliances. This section will discuss three key indicators that your water heater may be broken: leaks, unusual sounds, and poor water temperature.


Leaks are a common sign of a broken water heater. If you notice water pooling around the base of the heater or dripping from a connection, it might suggest that there is an issue with the tank, valve, or another component. Regularly inspect the area around your water heater for signs of leaks, and address any issues promptly to avoid potential hazards, such as carbon monoxide exposure and water damage.

Unusual Sounds

Another sign that your water heater may be malfunctioning is the presence of strange noises, such as banging, gurgling, or popping sounds. These sounds can often indicate that sediment has built up in the tank and is causing overheating or that an internal component is loose or damaged. Here are some common unusual sounds with their possible causes:

  • Banging – caused by the expansion and contraction of heating elements
  • Gurgling – often a result of water flow issues or sediment build-up
  • Popping – can indicate the presence of sediment in the tank or a faulty pressure relief valve

It’s important to address any unusual noises promptly to avoid potential hazards and ensure that your water heater continues to function efficiently.

Poor Water Temperature

If your water heater fails to provide consistent, adequately heated water, this may signal that the appliance is not functioning correctly. Fluctuations in water temperature can result from issues with the heating elements, a malfunctioning thermostat, or sediment build-up that impedes heat transfer. It is crucial to investigate and resolve any inconsistencies in water temperature to ensure the safe and efficient operation of your water heater.

Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Symptoms

Carbon monoxide poisoning can be life-threatening, and it is crucial to recognize its symptoms to seek immediate medical help. The severity of symptoms is often determined by the extent of exposure to carbon monoxide. In this section, we will discuss the symptoms of both mild and severe exposure.

Mild Exposure

Mild exposure to carbon monoxide can cause symptoms that may be mistaken for the flu or a cold. Some common symptoms include:

  • Headache
  • Dizziness
  • Shortness of breath
  • Weakness
  • Nausea
  • Vomiting

People can easily overlook these symptoms, especially since they can arise from other common illnesses.

Severe Exposure

Severe exposure to carbon monoxide presents more alarming symptoms, which should not be ignored. These include:

  • Confusion
  • Loss of consciousness
  • Chest pain
  • Seizures
  • High blood pressure
  • Irregular heartbeats

Severe exposure to carbon monoxide can lead to unconsciousness, coma, and even death if not addressed promptly.

It is essential to consider that some individuals may be more susceptible to carbon monoxide poisoning due to factors such as age or pre-existing medical conditions. In any case, if symptoms are observed, immediate medical attention is necessary to prevent further complications.

Preventing Carbon Monoxide Issues

Protecting your household from carbon monoxide (CO) issues caused by a broken water heater can be accomplished through proper measures. This section focuses on three primary prevention methods: proper ventilation, regular maintenance, and installing carbon monoxide detectors.

Proper Ventilation

Ensuring proper ventilation in the area where your water heater is located is crucial for minimizing carbon monoxide build-up. Poorly ventilated spaces can lead to an accumulation of CO, posing a serious health risk.

Here are some tips to achieve proper ventilation:

  • Make sure there is adequate room around the water heater for proper airflow.
  • Check for any obstructions near the water heater vent and keep it clear.
  • Regularly inspect the venting system for any damages or disconnections.
  • Seek professional advice if you have doubts about your water heater’s ventilation.

Regular Maintenance

By conducting regular maintenance on your water heater, you can prevent it from becoming a source of CO poisoning. Keeping a well-maintained water heater helps detect possible issues early and avoid major problems in the future.

Experts recommend the following maintenance practices:

Maintenance Task Frequency
Inspect water heater for signs of wear or damage Annually
Flush the system to remove sediment build-up Annually
Check for proper venting and gas connections Annually
Replace the anode rod to extend tank life Every 3-5 years

Installing Carbon Monoxide Detectors

Carbon monoxide detectors are essential safety devices that can alert you to hazardous CO levels in your home. It is advised to install detectors on each level of your home, as well as close to any fuel-burning appliances, such as water heaters.

When selecting and installing CO detectors, consider these recommendations:

  • Purchase detectors with a digital display to monitor CO levels in real-time.
  • Choose detectors with an audible alarm to ensure you are alerted promptly.
  • Place detectors within 15-20 feet of fuel-burning appliances.
  • Replace CO detectors according to the manufacturer’s guidelines.


In summary, a broken water heater can indeed contribute to the presence of carbon monoxide in a home. It is essential for homeowners to be aware of the risks associated with faulty water heaters and take necessary precautions to prevent carbon monoxide exposure.

Regular maintenance and inspection of water heaters, as well as the installation of carbon monoxide detectors, are crucial steps in ensuring the safety of a household. Additionally, being informed about how to identify the signs of carbon monoxide poisoning can be life-saving.

By taking these preventative measures, it is possible to reduce the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning and create a safer living environment for families.

Contact us to find out if it is time to replace your water heater.

We cover Blaine, Bloomington, Brooklyn Park, Eagan, Edina, Hastings, Maplewood, Minneapolis, Minnetonka, Roseville, North Saint Paul, Saint Paul, Saint Paul Park, South Saint Paul, Stillwater, West Lakeland, West Saint Paul, White Bear Lake, Woodbury, and many more locations.

Can’t find your town listed? Contact us at (651) 294-7798 to tell us where you live, so we can help you.

Schedule a HVAC repair anywhere in the Minneapolis or St. Paul area today by calling (651) 294-7798 or by requesting an estimate online.


Contact Us

1220 Cope Avenue East, Maplewood, MN 55109