We're Always Open Call Us Today!

Salt vs. Salt-Free Water Softeners: Everything You Should Consider

If you’re in the market for a water softener, you may have come across the terms “salt” and “salt-free” and wondered what the difference is. Simply put, salt water softeners use salt to remove hard minerals from water, while salt-free water softeners use a different method that doesn’t involve salt.

While both types of water softeners can effectively remove hard minerals, there are pros and cons to each. Salt water softeners are generally more effective at removing minerals and producing soft water, but they require regular maintenance and can add extra salt to your water supply. Salt-free water softeners, on the other hand, are low maintenance and don’t add salt to your water, but they may not be as effective at removing minerals and producing soft water.

What are Water Softeners?

Water softeners are devices that remove minerals from hard water, such as calcium and magnesium, and replace them with sodium or potassium ions. Hard water can cause a range of problems in the home, including scale buildup in pipes, appliances, and fixtures, as well as dry skin and hair. By removing the minerals that cause hardness, water softeners can help to prevent these issues and improve the overall quality of the water in your home.

How do Water Softeners Work?

Water softeners work by using a process called ion exchange. This involves passing hard water through a resin bed that contains small beads coated with sodium or potassium ions. As the hard water passes over the resin, the calcium and magnesium ions are attracted to the resin beads and replaced with sodium or potassium ions. The softened water is then passed through a separate tank to remove any excess sodium or potassium ions before it is distributed throughout the home.

Why are Water Softeners Needed?

Water softeners are needed because hard water can cause a range of problems in the home. Scale buildup in pipes, appliances, and fixtures can reduce their efficiency and lifespan, while also increasing energy bills. Hard water can also cause dry skin and hair, as well as making it more difficult to lather soap and shampoo. By removing the minerals that cause hardness, water softeners can help to prevent these issues and improve the overall quality of the water in your home.

Salt-Based Water Softeners

How do Salt-Based Water Softeners Work?

Salt-based water softeners work by exchanging hard minerals, such as calcium and magnesium, for sodium ions. The process involves two tanks: a resin tank and a brine tank. The resin tank contains small beads that are coated with a special resin that attracts hard minerals. When hard water flows through the resin tank, the hard minerals stick to the resin beads, effectively removing them from the water.

When the resin beads become saturated with hard minerals, the water softener enters a regeneration cycle. During this cycle, a salt solution from the brine tank is flushed through the resin tank, replacing the hard minerals on the resin beads with sodium ions. The hard minerals are then flushed out of the system, and the resin beads are ready to remove more hard minerals from incoming water.

Benefits of Salt-Based Water Softeners

  • Effective at removing hard minerals, resulting in softer water and less scale buildup in pipes and appliances
  • Relatively low maintenance, with only occasional refilling of the brine tank required
  • Proven technology with a long track record of success

Drawbacks of Salt-Based Water Softeners

  • Require regular replenishment of salt in the brine tank, which can be costly and inconvenient
  • Not suitable for individuals on a low-sodium diet or with certain health conditions, as the softened water can contain high levels of sodium
  • Can contribute to environmental concerns due to the discharge of salt and other chemicals into wastewater systems

Salt-Free Water Softeners

How do Salt-Free Water Softeners Work?

Salt-free water softeners use a different technology than traditional salt-based water softeners. Instead of removing the minerals from the water, they change the structure of the minerals so that they cannot stick to surfaces, including pipes and appliances. This process is called Template Assisted Crystallization (TAC) or Template Assisted Crystallization and Absorption (TAC/SAC).

TAC/SAC systems use a media bed of small beads that are coated with a template material. As water flows through the bed, the minerals in the water form microscopic crystals on the beads. These crystals are then attracted to each other and form larger, heavier crystals that are too large to stick to surfaces. The crystals then flow through the plumbing system and are flushed away.

Benefits of Salt-Free Water Softeners

  • Do not require salt or chemicals to operate, making them environmentally friendly
  • Do not produce wastewater, reducing the amount of water used in the softening process
  • Do not require electricity to operate, reducing energy consumption
  • Do not remove beneficial minerals from the water, making it healthier to drink
  • Do not require maintenance or salt refills, reducing overall costs

Drawbacks of Salt-Free Water Softeners

  • Do not remove minerals from the water, so they may not be as effective at preventing scale buildup as salt-based systems
  • May not work as well in areas with extremely hard water
  • May not be as effective at removing iron or manganese from the water
  • May be more expensive upfront than salt-based systems

Comparison between Salt-Based and Salt-Free Water Softeners

Cost Comparison

Salt-based water softeners are generally more expensive to install than salt-free alternatives. The initial cost of a salt-based system can range from $400 to $2,500, depending on the size of the unit and the complexity of the installation. In contrast, salt-free systems can be installed for as little as $150, making them a more affordable option for homeowners.

However, it’s important to note that salt-free systems may require more frequent maintenance and replacement of parts, which can add to the long-term cost of ownership.

Maintenance Comparison

Salt-based systems require regular maintenance, including adding salt to the tank and cleaning the resin bed. The cost of salt and other maintenance supplies can add up over time, and some homeowners may find the maintenance process to be time-consuming and inconvenient.

Salt-free systems, on the other hand, require less maintenance. They don’t require salt refills or resin bed cleanings, and they generally have a longer lifespan than salt-based systems. However, some salt-free systems may require periodic replacement of filters or other components.

Environmental Impact Comparison

Salt-based systems have a greater environmental impact than salt-free systems. The salt used in the softening process can contribute to high levels of sodium and chloride in the wastewater, which can harm aquatic life and contaminate groundwater. Additionally, the production and transportation of salt can have a significant carbon footprint.

Salt-free systems are generally considered to be more environmentally friendly. They don’t require the use of salt or other chemicals, and they don’t produce wastewater that can harm the environment.

Which Water Softener is Right for You?

Factors to Consider

Choosing the right water softener depends on several factors. First, consider the hardness of your water. If your water is extremely hard, a salt-based system may be the best choice. However, if your water is only slightly hard, a salt-free system may be sufficient.

Another factor to consider is the size of your household. If you have a large family or frequently have guests, a salt-based system may be more effective at removing minerals from your water. On the other hand, if you live alone or have a small family, a salt-free system may be a more cost-effective option.

It’s also important to consider your budget. Salt-based systems typically require more maintenance and may have higher upfront costs, while salt-free systems may be more expensive initially but require less maintenance in the long run.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the decision between a salt-based or salt-free water softener comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of your household. Consider the factors outlined above and do your research to make an informed decision.

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact Metro Heating & Cooling. We are always happy to help!

Schedule a HVAC repair anywhere in the Minneapolis or St. Paul area today by calling (651) 294-7798 or by requesting an estimate online.


Contact Us

1220 Cope Avenue East, Maplewood, MN 55109